A former Formula 1 driver has reignited debate by weighing in on a hypothetical head-to-head between two of the sport’s biggest names. Johnny Herbert has shared his view on how Lewis Hamilton and Fernando Alonso would compare if given identical machinery.
Herbert believes that, in equal cars, Alonso would have the edge over Hamilton. In his assessment, the Spaniard’s racecraft and adaptability would allow him to extract more performance over a full race weekend.
The comparison has gained traction as both drivers continue to compete deep into their careers. Despite their longevity, Hamilton and Alonso remain reference points on the grid, making any comparison between them especially compelling.
Herbert’s comments also reflect the enduring rivalry between the two champions, which dates back to their time as teammates at McLaren in 2007. That season laid the foundation for years of debate over who holds the upper hand.
While such a showdown may never happen in reality, the discussion highlights the respect both drivers command. Even in theoretical scenarios, Hamilton and Alonso continue to define conversations about greatness in Formula 1.
About the Author
